← Backtesting

Profit Factor, Win Rate and Expectancy: Which Metric to Trust

9 Nov 2026 · 2 min read

BullsEdges algo trading guide: Backtest reports are full of numbers. Learn what profit factor, win rate, expectancy, Sharpe and drawdown really tell you - and how each can mislead.

A backtest report can show dozens of statistics. A few matter much more than the rest, and each one can mislead if read alone.

BullsEdges algo trading application: Read expectancy, trade count and equity drawdown together; a headline win rate does not establish robust performance.

Profit factor

Gross profit / gross loss. Above 1 means the strategy made money.

  • 1.0-1.2: marginal; costs and live slippage can easily erase it.
  • 1.2-1.5: decent for a strategy with many trades.
  • 1.5-2.0: strong.
  • Above 2-3 on hundreds of trades: unusual - check for bugs such as lookahead bias.

Can mislead when: position sizes vary. A compounding or martingale strategy with growing lots can show a high profit factor driven by a few large trades. Calculating profit factor in R (each trade's result divided by its risk) removes the size effect.

Win rate

Winning trades / total trades.

Can mislead when: read without the average win and loss. A 90% win rate can lose money; a 35% win rate can be excellent.

Expectancy

Average profit per trade (after costs), or average R per trade. This is the most direct measure of the edge.

Can mislead when: based on few trades, or dominated by a few outliers. Check the median trade too.

Maximum drawdown

Largest peak-to-trough fall in equity.

Can mislead when: measured on balance only (hiding floating losses), or when the test period missed the worst market conditions. Assume live drawdown will be larger.

Sharpe and Sortino ratios

Return relative to volatility (Sortino only counts downside volatility). Useful for comparing strategies and portfolios.

Can mislead when: returns are not normally distributed - common for grids and option-like strategies, which show smooth returns until a sudden large loss.

Number of trades

Not a performance metric, but it decides how much you can trust all the others. Fewer than 100 trades is weak evidence.

What to check together

  1. Expectancy after costs - is there an edge?
  2. Number of trades - is it statistically meaningful?
  3. Profit factor in R - is the edge real, independent of sizing?
  4. Max equity drawdown - can you survive it?
  5. Consistency - is it positive in each year and each half of the data, long and short separately?
  6. Largest single loss - is there a hidden tail risk?

A quick sanity checklist

  • Remove the top 5 trades. Is it still profitable?
  • Double the spread. Is it still profitable?
  • Shift entries by one bar. Does it collapse?

BullsEdges takeaway for algo trading

No single number tells you a strategy is good. Expectancy tells you if there is an edge, the trade count tells you if you can believe it, and drawdown tells you if you can survive it.

Trading forex and gold carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for every investor. Past performance and backtests do not guarantee future results. This article is education, not financial advice.

Start your 1 month free trial

Full access to the Finoways Forex & XAUUSD algo, setup support included.