← Backtesting

MT5 Strategy Tester: Every Tick vs Real Ticks

20 Oct 2026 · 2 min read

BullsEdges algo trading guide: MT5 offers several tick modelling modes. Choosing the wrong one can turn a losing EA into a winner on paper. Here is what each mode does.

The MetaTrader 5 Strategy Tester can simulate price movement inside each bar in different ways. For many strategies the choice of mode changes the result more than any parameter.

BullsEdges algo trading application: Use a tick mode appropriate to the strategy's intrabar decisions and verify promising results with real-tick testing where available.

The modes

  • Open prices only: the EA only runs once per bar, at its open. Very fast, only valid for strategies that act strictly on bar opens.
  • 1 minute OHLC: uses the open, high, low and close of each M1 bar. Fast, but it has to guess the order of highs and lows inside each minute.
  • Every tick: MT5 generates synthetic ticks from M1 bars using a fixed pattern. More detail, but the ticks are invented.
  • Every tick based on real ticks: uses the broker's recorded tick history, including the real bid, ask and spread at each moment.

Why it matters

Inside a one-minute bar, price might go up then down, or down then up. Generated ticks follow a formula; real ticks follow what actually happened. For strategies that react to small moves, that difference decides whether a stop or a take-profit is hit first.

Strategies most affected:

  • Scalpers with small targets and stops.
  • Trailing stops that move with every tick.
  • Grid and straddle systems with pending orders close to price.
  • Anything sensitive to spread, because generated modes often use a fixed or simplified spread.

We have seen the same EA with the same inputs show a clear profit on generated ticks and a clear loss on real ticks. The difference came almost entirely from a tight trailing stop that looked perfect on invented ticks.

When generated ticks are fine

For strategies that trade on bar closes, hold trades for hours or days, and use stops and targets many times larger than the spread, generated and real ticks usually agree. Use the faster modes for exploration, and confirm the final version on real ticks.

Practical tips

  1. Download real tick history for the symbol and period before testing. The first run can take a while.
  2. Check the spread setting. "Current" spread uses today's spread for the whole history - unrealistic for news and rollover. Real-tick mode uses the recorded spread.
  3. Compare modes. If results change dramatically between modes, the strategy is sensitive to intrabar detail and needs extra caution.
  4. Watch for missing data. Tick history from some brokers has gaps. The tester log shows when data is missing.
  5. Use the same broker's data you will trade on. Different brokers have different spreads and different tick streams.

BullsEdges takeaway for algo trading

For any strategy that lives inside the bar - scalping, trailing, grids, news - trust only "every tick based on real ticks", and even then confirm with a forward test.

Trading forex and gold carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for every investor. Past performance and backtests do not guarantee future results. This article is education, not financial advice.

Start your 1 month free trial

Full access to the Finoways Forex & XAUUSD algo, setup support included.